• Register

Information for users from the old Q&A site
If you have an account from our old Q&A site, your account was transferred over, but you need to reset your password and confirm your email address.
Reset Password here
Confirm Email here

2,234 questions

3,904 answers


105,582 users

Help identify these rocks please!

0 votes

All of them were found on the Whitefish Point shoreline of Lake Superior. Couldn't scratch any of them with a pocketknife. Penny for scale.













2. Second picture is the same rock sitting on my phone's flashlight.



Thanks in advance!

asked Jul 13, 2018 by rushlash (150 points)

2 Answers

0 votes
Best answer
The difference between quartz and agate, (your quartz rock is the same chemically as agate, chert, flint, chalcedony...), is one is microcrystalline and the other macrocrystalline. Quartz has some cracks. Its crystals are large enough when you run your thumbnail over them, you can feel the grains. The quartz is macrocrystallinear. All the others I mentioned will appear shiny and smoother than all the other beach rocks, not have any cracks and where the rock is chipped you will see concave divots. They are known as conchoidal fractures. The same fractures flint knapping hominids used to form their handtools.

The others are smooth, even waxy, to the touch. The crystals are microscopic. If you run your fingernail across the rock it will not catch. These rocks are all very hard. You will not be able to scratch them with a common nail. I assume you wer looking for agates. If you want to know more, the Agate Lady, Karen Brzyz, wrote a book. I think it is one of the best. I am not sure the name is the right spelling. But she will be the person that comes up.

Whitefish is the most picked over beach. Vermillion Beach has more solitude, less traffic. Wildcat Beach, too. Just saying. My favorite is Crisp Point Beach at the Crisp Point lighthouse. Do yourself a favor. All those flashy pictures are cut and sanded specimens. Google rough lake superior agates and hit images. Those will show you what you are looking for.
answered Jul 13, 2018 by Weasel (58,850 points)
selected Jul 14, 2018 by rushlash
0 votes
The first three are quartz.
answered Jul 13, 2018 by Weasel (58,850 points)
I figured as much. Thanks for the input, though.

Related questions

0 votes
1 answer
0 votes
1 answer
asked Nov 14, 2017 by Pride (1,110 points)
0 votes
1 answer